As a year has passed since the onset of Israel's war on Gaza on October 7, 2023, Israel continues to use media misinformation as a key component of its military and propaganda strategy. It persists in promoting several claims that have been repeatedly debunked, most notably allegations of sexual assaults during Operation Al-Aqsa Flood.
Despite the absence of credible evidence to support these claims, Israel continues to disseminate them relentlessly, seizing every opportunity to reintroduce these narratives. This strategy aims to sway international public opinion, particularly targeting governments and global human rights organizations.
These allegations are integral to a systematic propaganda campaign designed to undermine the image of Palestinian resistance factions. Promoting such claims serves a strategic purpose: justifying Israel’s military actions in Gaza while simultaneously evading international accountability for violations committed against Palestinian civilians.
Israel also wields these accusations as a strategic tool to shape global public opinion, diverting attention from the actual violations perpetrated by its military in Gaza.
In this article, Misbar will analyze the key investigations conducted over the past year, focusing on debunking recurring allegations propagated by Israel without substantiating evidence. Additionally, we will highlight the propaganda tools integral to Israel’s media strategy throughout the ongoing war. By illuminating these efforts, we aim to provide a clearer understanding of the narratives shaping public perception and emphasize the importance of critical analysis in the face of widespread misinformation.
Persistent Sexual Assault Allegations During a Year of War Despite Ongoing Denials
From the outset of the war on Gaza, Israeli media, bolstered by official statements, propagated allegations that Palestinian resistance fighters perpetrated sexual assaults against Israeli women during Operation Al-Aqsa Flood. These claims gained significant traction across Israeli and international newspapers and television channels, serving as a strategic tool to damage the reputation of Palestinian resistance on the global stage. By amplifying these narratives, Israel aimed to shape public perception and deflect attention from the broader humanitarian crisis unfolding in Gaza.
Throughout the year of the war, Misbar has systematically refuted dozens of allegations regarding rape and sexual assault, with investigations revealing a complete lack of evidence to substantiate these claims. Despite this, such accusations persistently resurface and are used as justification for the crimes committed in Gaza.
Despite the lack of evidence and denials from international human rights organizations, Israeli media continues to insinuate these accusations as part of a deceptive campaign aimed at swaying global public opinion. Furthermore, Israeli female prisoners released by Hamas have testified that they were treated humanely and were not subjected to any assaults. These allegations are part of a broader strategy to demonize Palestinian resistance factions, equating them with terrorist organizations to justify the massacres committed by Israeli forces in Gaza. This narrative manipulation seeks to deflect scrutiny from the humanitarian implications of the conflict and legitimize ongoing military actions.
Despite repeated denials from female prisoners and human rights organizations, both Israel and the United States persist in promoting these claims. Notably, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been a prominent figure endorsing these allegations, reiterating them multiple times, including in his recent speech before the United Nations on September 27—just days before the first anniversary of the war.
Vice President Kamala Harris also addressed the same allegations of sexual assault during Operation Al-Aqsa Flood in her presidential debate with Donald Trump last September. This discussion is part of a broader pattern of statements made by both Israeli and American officials to promote these allegations. By bringing these allegations into high-profile political forums, such leaders aim to legitimize the narrative surrounding the conflict and bolster support for their positions, further entrenching these accusations in public discourse despite the absence of credible evidence.
Western Media Influenced by Israeli Assertions
Throughout the previous year, Misbar noted how Western media outlets echoed statements that promoted Israeli allegations while largely overlooking evidence that contradicted these claims. For instance, testimonies from Israeli female prisoners confirming they received humane treatment under Hamas were frequently ignored. Misbar's analysis of Western media coverage also revealed a concerning disregard for U.N. and human rights reports that documented "blatant human rights violations" suffered by Palestinian women at the hands of the Israeli army in Gaza and the West Bank since October 7, 2023.
The review further highlighted a pronounced bias in Western media coverage, with most major newspapers prioritizing claims of sexual violence against Israeli women while largely neglecting a U.N. report that condemns sexual violence against Palestinian women. This disparity is strikingly evident in how leading media outlets have failed to report on the U.N. findings fairly and equitably. Such selective reporting raises concerns about the media's role in shaping public perception and underscores the need for more balanced and comprehensive coverage of human rights issues.
Claims of Targeting Military Sites and Avoiding Civilian Casualties
Since the onset of the war on Gaza, Israel has consistently asserted that its military operations are solely aimed at targeting military sites and Hamas fighters, highlighting efforts to minimize civilian casualties. Despite being challenged by international human rights organizations, these claims persist in official statements and media narratives. Israeli officials maintain that their forces issue advance warnings to civilians before any attacks to mitigate casualties and take every possible precaution to avoid harming non-combatants.
However, the reality on the ground in Gaza paints a starkly different picture. Numerous media outlets have documented hundreds of instances confirming the direct targeting of civilians. Reports from the U.N. and human rights organizations highlight that Israeli airstrikes have struck civilian homes, schools, hospitals, and even makeshift refugee shelters for displaced people.
While Israel asserts that it prioritizes civilian lives, the grim reality reveals a different narrative, with over 41,909 Palestinians reported killed and 97,303 injured as of October 7, 2024. Throughout the year, Misbar has published numerous investigations providing compelling evidence of the direct targeting of civilians.
Furthermore, chilling testimonies from Israeli soldiers have surfaced, revealing a disturbing reality: they admitted to intentionally targeting women, children, and unarmed civilians as a form of amusement to alleviate boredom. These soldiers acknowledged indiscriminately shooting at both civilians and fighters, highlighting a troubling lack of distinction between combatants and non-combatants.
A closer analysis of these claims reveals a calculated media strategy designed to justify military operations in the eyes of the international community.
Despite Israel's persistent assertions of striving to minimize civilian casualties, a wealth of documented testimonies and international human rights reports unequivocally confirm that civilians have been directly targeted by Israeli forces. This stark contrast between rhetoric and reality highlights the urgent need for transparency and accountability in the discourse surrounding the ongoing war.
Israeli Allegations of Using Civilians as Human Shields
This claim—that Hamas uses civilians as human shields—has been a central part of Israel's justification for its military operations in Gaza. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly emphasized this point in speeches, including during his address to the U.S. Congress in July. Military spokespeople have also echoed the claim on social media and in both Arab and Western media, framing it as evidence that Hamas is responsible for the high number of civilian casualties.
Despite the persistent repetition of these allegations throughout the year, Israel has not produced conclusive material evidence accepted by any official U.N. or international body. Instead, the Israeli government has merely announced the initiation of investigations into these claims without disclosing their findings.
In contrast, Misbar has published multiple articles throughout the year, supported by evidence documenting numerous crimes that demonstrate Israel's use of Palestinian civilians as human shields during the war on Gaza and in the West Bank. This pattern suggests that the use of civilians as human shields is a systematic policy employed by the Israeli army. By accusing Palestinian resistance factions of such practices, Israel seeks to deflect responsibility for its actions, attempting to reverse the narrative and obscure the reality of its military operations. Misbar’s findings highlight the importance of critically analyzing these claims to understand the broader context of the conflict and the implications for civilian safety.
Claims of Improved Humanitarian Conditions in Gaza
Over the course of the year-long war on Gaza, Israel has consistently asserted its commitment to improving humanitarian conditions in the Strip. Israeli officials frequently claim they are facilitating the passage of aid through border crossings, portraying an image of goodwill amid the chaos. This narrative extends beyond local discussions; Israeli representatives reiterate these assertions in international forums and various media outlets, emphasizing what they describe as significant efforts to enhance living conditions for those in Gaza.
Contrary to Israel's claims, reports from international human rights organizations paint a starkly different picture. Rather than facilitating aid delivery, these reports highlight that Israel enforces stringent restrictions at the crossings, persistently hindering the entry of vital humanitarian assistance, such as food, medicine, and essential medical supplies. These limitations further worsen the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, deepening the plight of civilians grappling with critical shortages of basic necessities due to the ongoing blockade and the war's devastating aftermath.
In the face of persistent international calls for Israel to ease its restrictions and allow humanitarian aid to flow freely, the Israeli government frequently defends its policies by citing security concerns. Officials argue that these measures are essential to prevent weapons smuggling to resistance groups operating in the Strip. Nevertheless, United Nations reports reveal that such justifications do little to mitigate the escalating hardships faced by Palestinians in Gaza, who continue to suffer from severe shortages of food, medicine, and water.
In a series of earlier articles, Misbar has thoroughly debunked these Israeli assertions, underscoring that Israel continues to enforce restrictions on the entry of humanitarian aid. This exposes a glaring contradiction between the government’s repeated claims and the harsh realities on the ground, illustrating the disparity between rhetoric and the actual conditions faced by those in Gaza.
Attempts To Demonize Resistance Factions and Link Them to ISIS
One year into the Israeli war on Gaza, several claims pushed by Israel continue to permeate media narratives and diplomatic discussions, despite being repeatedly denied and debunked. This trend reflects Israel's strategy to fabricate a distorted media portrayal of the situation on the ground. Consequently, rigorous fact-checking and efforts to counter misinformation have become essential to clarify the truth and combat misleading narratives.
Media misinformation plays a crucial role in psychological warfare. Throughout the war on Gaza, Israel has sought to present itself as a victim engaged in a battle against "terrorists" who allegedly disregard the laws of war and human rights. This narrative serves to rationalize violence against Palestinian civilians while deflecting attention from the atrocities committed. In contrast, the task of documenting and sharing the truth becomes increasingly daunting amid these aggressive misinformation campaigns, which aim to legitimize the actions of the Israeli army in the Gaza Strip.
In this context, Israel and the United States have consistently sought to associate Hamas with ISIS, employing various strategies to reinforce this connection. By drawing parallels between these groups, they aim to frame Hamas as part of a broader global threat, thereby justifying military actions and policies against it. This tactic serves not only to vilify Hamas but also to garner international support for their stance on counterterrorism.
Among these strategies is the spread of alarming claims regarding rape and the burning of children. For example, Israeli media circulated a video allegedly showing a Hamas fighter threatening to spill French blood ahead of the Paris Olympics. Additionally, reports from Israeli journalists featured videos that purported to depict Hamas training children to handle weapons, along with images of the ISIS flag appearing at locations linked to Operation Al-Aqsa Flood.
Israeli Strategies in Promoting Misleading Claims
Israeli misinformation has extended beyond unsubstantiated statements, manifesting in various forms throughout the year of war. Israel employs a wide array of tactics to advance its narrative, including broadcasting misleading staged scenes as portrayals of events from October 7. Additionally, it capitalizes on media platforms and social networks in multiple languages, including Arabic, utilizing spokespersons and fake accounts to disseminate misinformation aimed at Arabic-speaking audiences.
Misbar has previously addressed these tactics in its reports, highlighting online campaigns that use hashtags in both Arabic and English to undermine the reality of crimes committed against Palestinians. Furthermore, Israel leverages artificial intelligence to amplify its narratives and create skepticism around any illustrative footage that aims to depict the scale of the disaster in Gaza, regardless of its clarity. This use of technology serves to manipulate public perception and divert attention from the serious violations occurring on the ground.
Misbar's ongoing analysis of these methods underscores the need for vigilance in discerning truth from disinformation in the current media landscape.
Read More
365 Days of War: How Misbar Exposed Israeli Misinformation on Gaza
Debunking Israel's Denial of Blocking Food Aid and Manufacturing Famine in Gaza
